左派必须拥抱法律与秩序——齐泽克 The left must embrace law and order
2023-07-30 01:36:11 来源: 哔哩哔哩
Two events have gripped public attention during this increasingly febrile summer: the failed military mutiny in Russia and the violent protests in France. Although the media has covered both in detail, a feature they share has passed unnoticed.
Looting and arson attacks spread through France after police shot dead a 17-year-old boy called Nahel in the Nanterre suburb of Paris on 27 June. In cities across the country, rioters erected barricades, lit fires and shot fireworks at police, who responded with tear gas, water cannons and stun grenades.Events took an even more ominous turn when the police began to act as autonomous agents, threatening to revolt unless President Emmanuel Macron resolved the crisis. The police released a statement that was nothing less than a crack in the edifice of state power: reacting to the riots, hard-liners in the police threatened to act against their own state.
(相关资料图)
The predictable leftist narrative is that the police is racially biased, French égalité is a fiction, young immigrants rebel because they have no future, and the way to solve this crisis is not more police oppression but a radical transformation of French society. Anger has been building for years and Nahel’s killing was the latest detonation that brought it into the open. Violent protests are a reaction to a problem, not the problem itself.
There is some truth to this narrative. When protests broke out in 2005 – after the deaths of two teenagers who were electrocuted while being pursued by police – the matrix of prejudices and exclusions that define the lives of immigrant youth in France was revealed. Yet overhauling society to solve the historic problems of identity, economic exclusion and colonial injustice is a problematic solution. It assumes a progressive outcome when none seems forthcoming.
The protesters’ targeting of local buses, for example, so crucial in transporting workers from the low-income suburbs on the edge of Paris, indicates two things: the riots have wrecked the infrastructure that sustains the livelihoods of ordinary people, and the victims of the destruction are the poor, not the rich.
Public protests and uprisings can play a positive role if they are sustained by an emancipatory vision, such as the 2013-14 Maidan uprising in Ukraine and the ongoing Iranian protests triggered by Kurdish women who have refused to wear the burka. Even the threat of violent action is sometimes necessary for political resolution. Two historic victories canonised by the liberal commentariat – the rise to power of the African National Congress (ANC) in South Africa and the US civil rights protests led by Martin Luther King Jr – were only possible because they were backed by the prospect of violence by the radical wing of the ANC and more militant black Americans. The negotiations over ending apartheid in South Africa and abolishing racial segregation in the US succeeded because of these threats.
Yet this is not the situation in France today, where violent rebellion is unlikely to end with any kind of progressive settlement for the wretched of the Earth. If law and order are not promptly restored, the final outcome may well be the election of Marine le Pen, the leader of the hard-right National Rally party, as the new president. The anti-immigrant nationalists are in power in Sweden, Norway and Italy – why not in France? Macron has presented himself as a technocrat with no firm political stance. But a position that was once seen as a strength now looks like a fatal weakness.
In Russia, it was difficult to miss the comic nature of Yevgeny Prigozhin’s march on Moscow. It was over within 36 hours after the Kremlin offered him a deal. Prigozhin has avoided a legal trial but has been forced to withdraw his mercenaries from Ukraine and move to Belarus. We don’t know enough to say what really happened: was his march meant as a full-scale attack to occupy Moscow, or was it an empty threat, a gesture not meant to be realised, as Prigozhin himself has suggested? The entire episode may also have been a brute form of business negotiation – an attempt to prevent the passing of a law which stipulated that irregular forces such as the Wagner Group had to fall under the command of the regular armed forces.
Whether it was an attempted coup or a business negotiation-by-mutiny, the event bears witness to the reality that Russia is becoming a failed state – a state that has to treat uncontrolled military gangs as partners in a grubby deal.
The events in France and Russia are part of a trend in Europe towards instability, crisis and disorder. Today, failed states are not only in the Global South, from Somalia to Pakistan to South Africa. If we measure a failed state by the crack-up of state power, as well as the heightened atmosphere of ideological civil war, deadlocked assemblies and the growing insecurity of public spaces, then Russia, France, the UK and even the US should also be understood in similar terms.
On 19 June 2022, Texas Republicans approved measures declaring that President Joe Biden “was not legitimately elected” and rebuked the Republican senator, John Cornyn, for taking part in bipartisan talks about gun control. They also voted on a platform that declared homosexuality “an abnormal lifestyle choice” and called for Texas schoolchildren “to learn about the humanity of the preborn child”.
The first measure – declaring that Biden’s election was invalid – is a clear move towards a “cold” civil war in the US: the delegitimisation of the political order. In France, talk of a coming civil war is de rigueur on the hard right. Speaking on French radio on 30 June, the hard-right politician-polemicist Éric Zemmour, described the riots as the “beginnings of a civil war, an ethnic war”.
In this general situation, the left must assume the slogan of law and order as its own. One of the most depressing facts in recent history is that the only case of a violent revolutionary crowd invading the seat of power was on 6 January 2021, when Donald Trump’s supporters stormed the US Capitol in Washington DC. They viewed the election as illegitimate, a theft organised by corporate elites. Left-liberals reacted with a mix of fascination and horror. Some of my friends cried, saying: “We should be doing something like this!” There was both envy and condemnation as they watched “ordinary” people breaking into the pinnacle of state sovereignty, creating a carnival that momentarily suspended the rules of public life.
By launching a popular attack on the seat of power, has the populist right stolen the left’s resistance to the prevailing system? Is our only choice now between parliamentary elections controlled by corrupted elites or uprisings controlled by the hard right? No wonder Steve Bannon, the ideologist of the populist right, declares himself a “Leninist for the 21st century”: “I’m a Leninist. Lenin… wanted to destroy the state, and that’s my goal too. I want to bring everything crashing down, and destroy all of today’s establishment.” While the populist right was ecstatic about 6 January, the liberal left acted like good old conservatives, asking for the National Guard to crush the rebellion.
At the roots of this weird situation, we find a unique combination of anarchy and savage authoritarianism. We are entering a time of insurrection and mobocracy, as well as the unprecedented concentration of power in the hands of a few. It is what the philosopher Catherine Malabou calls “the combination – at once senseless, monstrous, and unprecedented – of savage verticality and uncontrollable horizontality”. And as the state’s “social function” has been eroded through years of austerity, it can now only express itself “through the use of violence”.
That is why it is crucial not just to dismiss the state as the instrument of domination. In natural disasters, public health catastrophes and periods of social unrest, progressive forces must try and seize state power and use it, not only to calm people’s fears in times of emergency, but also to fight those fears – racist, xenophobic, sexist, anti-progressive – artificially concocted to keep populations in check.
The left shouldn’t be afraid to add to its tasks ensuring the safety of ordinary people: there are clear signs of the growing decay of manners, of youthful gangs terrorising public spaces, from stations to shopping malls. Mentioning this decay is often dismissed as reactionary, with the insistence that we must look at the “deeper social roots” of such phenomena, such as unemployment and institutional racism.
Yet if the left disregards public safety, it is conceding to the enemy an important domain of dissatisfaction that, in a time of anarchy, pushes people to the right. Everyday insecurity hurts the poor much more than the rich who live calmly in their gated communities.
标签:
为您推荐
精彩放送
热门文章
-
死亡换手率是不好的意思吗?换手率与量比的关系是什么?
-
股票除权除息后就是分红了吗?为什么要除权除息?
-
股票a杀指的是什么意思?股票的主力是指谁?
-
什么是分级基金怎样理解?分级基金有哪些代码?
-
加息对大宗商品是利好还是利空?加息与降息对经济的影响有哪些?
-
增发股票的意思怎么理解?股票非公开增发是什么意思?
-
什么是定期折算和不定期折算?不定期份额折算会亏损吗?
-
博弈是什么意思如何理解?博弈的通俗说法是什么?
-
格力是国企吗?董明珠是打工还是老板?董明珠哪里人?
-
指数基金和股票基金有什么区别?买基金买哪一种基金比较好?
-
6月30日晚市要闻 _焦点
-
今日播报!陆家嘴:拟以发行股份方式购买陆家嘴集团持有的昌邑公司100%股权、东袤公司30%股权
精彩图片
-
成本大减!新一轮的旗舰大战也将在即将到来的9月正式拉开帷幕
-
博览会开幕 中国首款具有自主知识产权的国产通用型科学计算软件正式发布
-
技术下降!Intel独立显卡驱动一次评测就发现43个Bug
-
高性能的台式机彻底告别“光污染” 雷克沙推出简洁纯白外观设计
-
韩国媒体率先报道:三星电子236层NAND闪存预计年内开始生产 市场竞争更激烈
-
新科技!苹果正在积极研发某种形式的AR/VR头显或智能眼镜
-
谷歌测试开展新功能 向用户展示哪些云流媒体服务拥有特定的视频游戏
-
支付宝积极响应国家为小微降费的政策号召 一年降费让利近80亿
-
京东汽车就与浦林成山旗下新能源车轮胎品牌浦林达成战略合作 助力轮胎“电动化转型”
-
苹果新专利公布:暗示未来 iPhone手机或许有陶瓷材质版
-
盖茨和韩国能源供应商SK共同牵头 其中SK投资2.5亿美元
-
海底捞早已经捞不动了 据统计上半年最高亏损达2.97亿
热文
-
电影《爱犬奇缘》8月22日七夕上映,世界不能没有修狗!
-
美国劳工群体为何走上街头?
-
侯友宜最新民调25%,郭正亮示警:非常危险
-
中国女足 不止于此!蒙牛大力支持铿锵玫瑰要强绽放
-
天开园首家金融机构开业
-
博时富通一年定开债发起式基金经理发生变更
-
迎战杜苏芮 全市织密织牢防御台风网
-
坐骨神经痛的症状有哪些?坐骨神经痛要如何缓解?
-
吴奇隆带儿子游玩, 为儿子暖心的驱蚊,父爱满满!
-
FURY|牧马人侧杠穿越风全机械连接的结构唤醒系列-侧杠
-
受“杜苏芮”尾流影响 未来十天泉州市多降雨
-
骗子不收手 反诈不停歇:人和派出所抓获五名犯罪嫌疑人
-
工业高科技用来煎牛排,稻谷壳当材料做环保轮胎……今年进博会参展商新品抢先体验
-
“深圳元素”点亮青春盛会!深企“硬核”科技赋能成都大运会
-
孙燕姿光脚唱逆光 孙燕姿逆光mv事件)
-
联合国官员:联合国仍在向尼日尔提供人道主义援助
-
补齐县域成长型企业人才短板
-
人才培育要瞄准产业需求
-
科博达:股东拟减持不超过3.53万股
-
中国全力应对超强台风“杜苏芮”,福建超41.6万人被疏散至安全地点
-
云南白药(000538):7月28日北向资金增持91.05万股
-
招商局港口(00144.HK):7月28日南向资金增持80.2万股
-
“百姓选什么 政府买什么” 老百姓可一键选择自己喜欢的图书
-
百分之一是多少利息(百分之一是多少怎么算)
-
简约 绿色 精彩 ——成都大运会开幕式科技亮点纷呈
-
摩托车后鼓刹更换刹车片(标致508刹车片多久更换?)
-
成都大运会丨成都大运场馆累计开放近8万小时带动全民健身
-
山东黄金(01787.HK):7月28日南向资金增持80万股
-
高通骁龙782处理器怎么样(mt6753处理器相当于高通的那个型号)
-
股票行情快报:丽江股份(002033)7月28日主力资金净买入120.07万元
-
炎炎夏日,盆栽生机润泽:30个夏季高温天气居家盆栽的浇水秘籍!
-
在中国戏曲里邂逅一场爱情 在《戏宇宙》里感受独特浪漫
-
利率与房价齐飞 入门级住宅对美国首次购房者已可望而不可及
-
明天6时起,恢复!厦门最新发布
-
11个重点项目签约入驻珠海高新区 预计达产产值超51亿元
-
与妻书知识点归纳整理 与妻书知识点
-
上海市委常委会会议:全力推动上海自贸试验区建设迈上新台阶
-
中国中小企业发展促进中心主任单立坡:将“三赋”行动落到实处 助力中小企业实现专精特新之路
-
气鼓病相当于现在什么病(气鼓)
-
【视频】新车到手可自己没驾照,咋办?他直接买了本假证
-
黑龙江鲤鱼炖豆腐 鲤鱼炖豆腐
-
长沙挂牌8宗地块 总起始价近41亿元
-
历史一刻!成都大运会主火炬点燃
-
京城“神盘”国安府热炒背后 中信庄胜纠纷十年仍在“磋商”
-
路面破损钢管裸露很危险 综合行政执法队快速处置
-
天津市与中国华电签署深化战略合作协议
-
外卖小哥享用“法治大餐” 姑苏区司法局开展“送法上门”服务
-
黑色回廊跑酷2官网在哪下载 最新官方下载安装地址
-
交通运输部:持续抓好港口危险货物安全管理 坚决防范重特大港口生产安全事故发生
-
国家发改委答21记者:持续推进绿色智能家电下乡等活动